Detective Cole Phelps of L.A. Noire is good at his job, no doubt about that, but even the best of us have the occasional “oh crap” moment. Unfortunately for Phelps, those moments tend to occur more frequently if you’re a video game character operating at the behest of a mildly-sadistic gamer who controls your every move. Our friends at Game Front put together a collection of Phelps’ more awkward interrogation incidents, including a few in which he accuses elderly women of orchestrating elaborate murder plots. Then again, you can never be too careful with people who willingly eat prunes and bran cereal every day. Too shady. Check out Cole Phelps’ worst detective moments below.