You may remember that last week, we introduced you to IYHSTDSN (If You Haven’t Seen This, Do So Now), with video of a truly inflammatory twerking disaster. Well, it turns out that, much like children whose parents tell them they’ve eaten all the Halloween candy, we’ve fallen victim to a brilliant Jimmy Kimmel prank. To which we can only say, a) we weren’t the only ones! And b) well played, sir, well played.

(And once again, thanks, Buzzfeed!)